While I was at the Apple Store today, I checked out the brand new iPad. I really want to get one to replace the six-year-old Powerbook I have at home. My wife and I both have work laptops for heavy lifting, but the iPad seems perfect for the things we do most on our laptops at home: the web, video, email, and photos.
The iPad is smaller than I expected, but when I picked it up, the device was heavier than I thought. I was also surprised by how difficult typing was while holding the device. On an iPhone, I can type quickly with both thumbs, but with the iPad, I have to hold the device with one hand while typing with the other. And unlike the iPhone which seems molded to my hand, I found the iPad’s shape a bit awkward to hold.
I left a little disappointed, but driving back, I suddenly realized the real problem: Apple screwed up the iPad shopping experience. In the store, I had to use the iPad while standing, but I would almost never use the iPad while standing at home.
Where’s the couch?
When Apple unveiled the iPad at a press event in January, the iPad was not the only thing appearing on-stage for the first time. There was also a large couch in the center of the stage.
Instead of demoing the new product while standing or sitting at a desk like usual, Steve Jobs demonstrated the iPad while seated at a couch. The new iPad TV ad, too, shows people using the iPad while seated on couches. But when you go to an Apple Store to try it for yourself, the iPad is displayed on the same standing tables that display Macs, Macbooks, iPods, and iPhones.
Apple should create a lounge in each store where people can sit and use the iPad like they will in their own homes. Or, add some bar stools, so people can at least get an idea of what it’s like to read an iPad while drinking coffee. This will give shoppers a better idea of what it’s like to actually use the product while simultaneously sending the message, “The iPad is different from any other device.”
Using an iPad while standing is clumsier compared to when you’re sitting on the couch. And when used at a desk, it’s best to have the iPad standing in a dock with a bluetooth keyboard or resting at a tilt in the iPad Case.
Desktops and laptops are mostly used on a desk, and iPods and iPhones are easily used while standing up. But if Jobs’ demo and Apple’s own ads are any clue, Apple believes that the iPad is best used as a casual device while lounging on a couch. So, help shoppers use the device like they will at home, and put some couches in the store.
The Las Vegas Sun has perhaps the most innovative newspaper website in the country.
Historically, the Sun has been the much smaller competitor to the Las Vegas Review-Journal, but as newspapers move online, the Sun is threatening to surpass its larger rival (for a history of newspapers in Las Vegas, see “A Century of Journalism“). Over the last twelve months, lasvegassun.com has grown 112% while lvrj.com has grown only 20%. And in January, lasvegassun.com almost passed lvrj.com for most unique visitors.
Brian Greenspun went out a couple years ago and hired a team of leading innovators in online journalism. Dave Toplikar relaunched the Sun’s website on January 10, 2008 with a number of unique features, and Rob Curley joined as President and Executive Editor of Greenspun Interactive last summer. They built an all–star staff of online journalism’s chief innovators. Month-by-month, the site has integrated content from Greenspun Media’s weekly and monthly publications, and the Interactive team has added photography, blogs, video, and other content unique to the website.
The whiz kids at Greenspun Interactive probably already know what they want to do next, but here is one idea from a fan and reader to improve the reader experience and generate revenue.
Target to My Neighborhood
The local newspaper is one of the best ways residents can connect to their neighborhoods and the larger community. And the Internet allows people to connect to their neighborhoods in ways they never could with a print newspaper.
LasVegasSun.com is starting to pull together the right editorial components. They already have some local content on their site for different parts of town, including articles from the Home News, an Event Calendar, and a Crime Map (if anyone from Greenspun Interactive is reading, the RSS feed for Summerlin is listed incorrectly and the auto-discover RSS feed on the Summerlin section is the main news feed, not the one for Summerlin). They’ve started building a restaurant listings database (please simplify the ratings to be as simple as Yelp). And I can see photos and videos from both journalists and readers from my part of town. But I have to go find all this content.
To make it all easier to find, I would like to tell LasVegasSun.com which part of town I live in, so they can tell me about what is going on in my neighborhood. ZIP code is too broad (at least in Las Vegas) and giving them my address seems creepy…sub-ZIP seems perfect. But I don’t know my sub-zip, so show me a map of Las Vegas with hotspots for each sub-ZIP.
Then, give me news and events for my neighborhood, restaurant and business ratings in my area. If I tell you which neighborhood I live in, you can provide the relevant local news, coupons, and ads I want while simultaneously giving advertisers the local targeting they desire.
If you want, you can take it even further, and let me tell you even more about myself in exchange for more personalized information. If I have kids, let me tell you which school they go to or which sports leagues they play in to get me news, schedules, scores, and announcements. Let me tell you my housing development in exchange for news from my HOA. By providing news and information targeted toward me, you get permission to show me ads targeted to me.
Readers Want Local Advertising…If It’s Done Right
Most of the Sun’s innovations have been on the editorial side, but I would like to see them also innovate on the advertising side. Some people think advertising is just a nuisance that pays the bills and distracts from the editorial content, but advertising can be valuable when it’s anticipated, personal, and relevant (See Seth Godin’s talk on permission marketing). My wife loves to look at the Sunday paper just for the insert ads of her favorite stores. I love getting a coupon to try the new restaurant down the street. We use chose our dry cleaners because they were close and they sent us some coupons. In fact, we bought an Entertainment book because it’s full of Regal movie coupons, and we find a few coupons for restaurants we already love or want to try.
So offer a coupon directory in exchange for my sub-ZIP. I want two-for-ones and 10% off coupons from businesses nearby: Fabulous Freddy’s, Fazio Cleaners, Papa John’s, Regal Cinemas, Original Pancake House, etc. Plus, now that you know my sub-ZIP, advertisers can target their banner ads on the site just like they target direct mail. Instead of showing a general ad from Station Casinos that I don’t care about, you can show a specific ad for the bowling alley that just opened or the upcoming concert at the Station near me.
Of course, this idea might work for other newspapers as well. Readers get ads they want to see along with the editorial they want just by giving the local newspaper a little information about which neighborhood they live in. And advertisers can target based on that information to give the newspaper the revenue it needs to keep doing journalism.
Bonus Marketing Idea: When I move to Las Vegas, send me a Neighborhood Guide packet (you could even put an illustration of the “Welcome to Fabulous Las Vegas” sign on the envelope. Include some printed information on my neighborhood and a couple printed coupons with a “Get Your Neighborhood News and More Discounts at LasVegasSun.com”).
I used to think that marketing was just doing things like designing packaging, coming up with cool ads, and figuring out where to place ads. That all changed when I watched this video of Seth Godin speaking at Google. I got that marketing is a much more strategic endeavor that decides whether or not something spreads. I’ve been hooked ever since.